{ "title": "Local vs Remote MCP Visual Specifications", "schemaVersion": "1.0", "researchFreeze": "2026-08-26", "protocolRevision": "MCP 2026-07-28", "sourcePackage": "research/10", "integrityNote": "All 108 listed ordinary archive payloads verify. The package contains two incompatible numeric source namespaces; public records preserve an explicit archive namespace and never resolve IDs across families.", "evidencePolicy": "Only manually curated build_context source groups appear in sourceIds. Raw row tokens are preserved under archive and are not treated as publication citations.", "checkedAt": "2026-08-26", "count": 18, "records": [ { "Title": "Local MCP Architecture", "Purpose": "Show host, client, stdio subprocess, local OS resources and credential boundary.", "Underlying data": "Current stdio spec; local product patterns", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "Label process authority and stderr/stdout separation.", "Caption": "A local MCP server launched as a subprocess over stdio.", "Accessible alt text": "Diagram showing an AI host launching a local MCP server and reaching files and tools.", "id": "R10-VIS001", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 1, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Local MCP Architecture", "Purpose": "Show host, client, stdio subprocess, local OS resources and credential boundary.", "Underlying data": "Current stdio spec; local product patterns", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "Label process authority and stderr/stdout separation.", "Caption": "A local MCP server launched as a subprocess over stdio.", "Accessible alt text": "Diagram showing an AI host launching a local MCP server and reaching files and tools." } }, "publicationStatus": "implemented", "asset": "/visuals/local-remote-deployment-map.svg", "adaptationNote": "The reader diagram adds remote and hybrid panels so deployment boundaries can be compared in one accessible figure." }, { "Title": "Remote MCP Architecture", "Purpose": "Show HTTPS endpoint, gateway/load balancer, replicas, identity and upstream SaaS.", "Underlying data": "Current Streamable HTTP and authorization specs", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "Do not include Mcp-Session-Id in modern diagram.", "Caption": "Modern remote MCP uses independent HTTP requests and ordinary infrastructure.", "Accessible alt text": "Diagram of a host connecting through HTTPS and OAuth to replicated MCP servers.", "id": "R10-VIS002", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 2, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Remote MCP Architecture", "Purpose": "Show HTTPS endpoint, gateway/load balancer, replicas, identity and upstream SaaS.", "Underlying data": "Current Streamable HTTP and authorization specs", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "Do not include Mcp-Session-Id in modern diagram.", "Caption": "Modern remote MCP uses independent HTTP requests and ordinary infrastructure.", "Accessible alt text": "Diagram of a host connecting through HTTPS and OAuth to replicated MCP servers." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Hybrid Host", "Purpose": "One host connected to local files/IDE and remote SaaS servers.", "Underlying data": "Host and deployment matrices", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Mark separate trust zones.", "Caption": "A capable host can combine local and remote servers.", "Accessible alt text": "Diagram of one AI host connected to both local and remote MCP servers.", "id": "R10-VIS003", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 3, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Hybrid Host", "Purpose": "One host connected to local files/IDE and remote SaaS servers.", "Underlying data": "Host and deployment matrices", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Mark separate trust zones.", "Caption": "A capable host can combine local and remote servers.", "Accessible alt text": "Diagram of one AI host connected to both local and remote MCP servers." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "stdio Message Flow", "Purpose": "Process spawn, newline messages, stderr logging, cancellation and shutdown.", "Underlying data": "S003", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "No server-to-client JSON-RPC requests in current core.", "Caption": "Current stdio lifecycle and framing.", "Accessible alt text": "Sequence diagram for stdio MCP messages.", "id": "R10-VIS004", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 4, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "stdio Message Flow", "Purpose": "Process spawn, newline messages, stderr logging, cancellation and shutdown.", "Underlying data": "S003", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "No server-to-client JSON-RPC requests in current core.", "Caption": "Current stdio lifecycle and framing.", "Accessible alt text": "Sequence diagram for stdio MCP messages." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Streamable HTTP Flow", "Purpose": "POST, JSON or SSE, MRTR, subscriptions/listen.", "Underlying data": "S004", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "Distinguish request-scoped from long-lived subscription streams.", "Caption": "Current Streamable HTTP message flow.", "Accessible alt text": "Sequence diagram for modern Streamable HTTP.", "id": "R10-VIS005", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 5, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Streamable HTTP Flow", "Purpose": "POST, JSON or SSE, MRTR, subscriptions/listen.", "Underlying data": "S004", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "Distinguish request-scoped from long-lived subscription streams.", "Caption": "Current Streamable HTTP message flow.", "Accessible alt text": "Sequence diagram for modern Streamable HTTP." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Remote Architecture by Era", "Purpose": "Compare 2024 HTTP+SSE, 2025 session Streamable HTTP and 2026 stateless core.", "Underlying data": "S009 S010 S004", "Protocol version": "2024-2026", "Uncertainty notes": "Keep each frozen.", "Caption": "Remote MCP architecture changed in three major transport eras.", "Accessible alt text": "Timeline comparing three remote MCP architectures.", "id": "R10-VIS006", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 6, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Remote Architecture by Era", "Purpose": "Compare 2024 HTTP+SSE, 2025 session Streamable HTTP and 2026 stateless core.", "Underlying data": "S009 S010 S004", "Protocol version": "2024-2026", "Uncertainty notes": "Keep each frozen.", "Caption": "Remote MCP architecture changed in three major transport eras.", "Accessible alt text": "Timeline comparing three remote MCP architectures." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Local Security Boundary", "Purpose": "Package/config → process → files/env/network.", "Underlying data": "Security matrix", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Show sandbox as optional control, not guarantee.", "Caption": "Local server risk centers on code authority.", "Accessible alt text": "Threat diagram for a local MCP process.", "id": "R10-VIS007", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 7, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Local Security Boundary", "Purpose": "Package/config → process → files/env/network.", "Underlying data": "Security matrix", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Show sandbox as optional control, not guarantee.", "Caption": "Local server risk centers on code authority.", "Accessible alt text": "Threat diagram for a local MCP process." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Remote Security Boundary", "Purpose": "Client/token → endpoint → tenant service → upstream system.", "Underlying data": "Authorization and security matrices", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Show object authorization at upstream.", "Caption": "Remote risk centers on identity, tenancy and service operation.", "Accessible alt text": "Threat diagram for a remote MCP service.", "id": "R10-VIS008", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 8, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Remote Security Boundary", "Purpose": "Client/token → endpoint → tenant service → upstream system.", "Underlying data": "Authorization and security matrices", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Show object authorization at upstream.", "Caption": "Remote risk centers on identity, tenancy and service operation.", "Accessible alt text": "Threat diagram for a remote MCP service." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "OAuth Flow", "Purpose": "Protected resource metadata, authorization server, PKCE, token and MCP request.", "Underlying data": "S005 S052-S057", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "OAuth authorizes HTTP; not stdio.", "Caption": "Remote delegated authorization flow.", "Accessible alt text": "OAuth sequence for an MCP remote server.", "id": "R10-VIS009", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 9, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "OAuth Flow", "Purpose": "Protected resource metadata, authorization server, PKCE, token and MCP request.", "Underlying data": "S005 S052-S057", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "OAuth authorizes HTTP; not stdio.", "Caption": "Remote delegated authorization flow.", "Accessible alt text": "OAuth sequence for an MCP remote server." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Secret Locations", "Purpose": "Map local env/keychain and remote vault/token store.", "Underlying data": "Secret matrix", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Do not include actual secrets.", "Caption": "Secret placement differs by deployment.", "Accessible alt text": "Diagram showing where credentials are stored in local and remote MCP.", "id": "R10-VIS010", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 10, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Secret Locations", "Purpose": "Map local env/keychain and remote vault/token store.", "Underlying data": "Secret matrix", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Do not include actual secrets.", "Caption": "Secret placement differs by deployment.", "Accessible alt text": "Diagram showing where credentials are stored in local and remote MCP." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Single User vs Multi-Tenant", "Purpose": "Compare one local process, single-tenant remote and multi-tenant remote.", "Underlying data": "Deployment taxonomy", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Avoid implying all remote is multi-tenant.", "Caption": "User population is separate from network location.", "Accessible alt text": "Three-column deployment comparison.", "id": "R10-VIS011", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 11, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Single User vs Multi-Tenant", "Purpose": "Compare one local process, single-tenant remote and multi-tenant remote.", "Underlying data": "Deployment taxonomy", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Avoid implying all remote is multi-tenant.", "Caption": "User population is separate from network location.", "Accessible alt text": "Three-column deployment comparison." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Enterprise Gateway", "Purpose": "Approved servers, identity broker, policy, DLP, audit.", "Underlying data": "Enterprise architectures", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Show gateway cannot replace downstream auth.", "Caption": "Gateway centralizes policy but not business authorization.", "Accessible alt text": "Enterprise MCP gateway architecture.", "id": "R10-VIS012", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 12, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Enterprise Gateway", "Purpose": "Approved servers, identity broker, policy, DLP, audit.", "Underlying data": "Enterprise architectures", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Show gateway cannot replace downstream auth.", "Caption": "Gateway centralizes policy but not business authorization.", "Accessible alt text": "Enterprise MCP gateway architecture." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Serverless Remote MCP", "Purpose": "Request routed to function/worker, external state and upstream API.", "Underlying data": "Serverless matrix", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "Show cold start/state externalization.", "Caption": "Stateless protocol fits serverless but applications still keep state.", "Accessible alt text": "Serverless MCP deployment diagram.", "id": "R10-VIS013", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 13, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Serverless Remote MCP", "Purpose": "Request routed to function/worker, external state and upstream API.", "Underlying data": "Serverless matrix", "Protocol version": "2026-07-28", "Uncertainty notes": "Show cold start/state externalization.", "Caption": "Stateless protocol fits serverless but applications still keep state.", "Accessible alt text": "Serverless MCP deployment diagram." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "MCPB Local Distribution", "Purpose": "Bundle manifest, install review, config, local stdio process.", "Underlying data": "S020 S049", "Protocol version": "Current product", "Uncertainty notes": "Host-specific distribution, not core protocol.", "Caption": "MCPB packages local servers for easier installation.", "Accessible alt text": "MCP bundle installation and execution lifecycle.", "id": "R10-VIS014", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 14, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "MCPB Local Distribution", "Purpose": "Bundle manifest, install review, config, local stdio process.", "Underlying data": "S020 S049", "Protocol version": "Current product", "Uncertainty notes": "Host-specific distribution, not core protocol.", "Caption": "MCPB packages local servers for easier installation.", "Accessible alt text": "MCP bundle installation and execution lifecycle." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Cost Responsibility Map", "Purpose": "Place packaging/support on local and hosting/identity/SLO on remote.", "Underlying data": "Cost framework", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "No invented dollar amounts.", "Caption": "Costs shift rather than disappear.", "Accessible alt text": "Cost responsibility comparison for local and remote MCP.", "id": "R10-VIS015", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 15, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Cost Responsibility Map", "Purpose": "Place packaging/support on local and hosting/identity/SLO on remote.", "Underlying data": "Cost framework", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "No invented dollar amounts.", "Caption": "Costs shift rather than disappear.", "Accessible alt text": "Cost responsibility comparison for local and remote MCP." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Decision Tree", "Purpose": "Resource location → host support → users → credentials → availability.", "Underlying data": "Decision framework", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Include hybrid outcome.", "Caption": "Choose deployment from constraints, not ideology.", "Accessible alt text": "Decision tree for choosing local, remote or hybrid MCP.", "id": "R10-VIS016", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 16, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Decision Tree", "Purpose": "Resource location → host support → users → credentials → availability.", "Underlying data": "Decision framework", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Include hybrid outcome.", "Caption": "Choose deployment from constraints, not ideology.", "Accessible alt text": "Decision tree for choosing local, remote or hybrid MCP." } }, "publicationStatus": "implemented", "asset": "/visuals/local-remote-decision.svg", "adaptationNote": "The reader diagram implements the supplied nine-question deployment framework." }, { "Title": "Host Support Heat Map", "Purpose": "Hosts vs local stdio, remote HTTP, OAuth and private bridge.", "Underlying data": "Host compatibility audit", "Protocol version": "Snapshot 2026-08-26", "Uncertainty notes": "Mark live-check required.", "Caption": "Current hosts support different deployment forms.", "Accessible alt text": "Heat map of MCP host transport support.", "id": "R10-VIS017", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 17, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Host Support Heat Map", "Purpose": "Hosts vs local stdio, remote HTTP, OAuth and private bridge.", "Underlying data": "Host compatibility audit", "Protocol version": "Snapshot 2026-08-26", "Uncertainty notes": "Mark live-check required.", "Caption": "Current hosts support different deployment forms.", "Accessible alt text": "Heat map of MCP host transport support." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" }, { "Title": "Failure Domains", "Purpose": "Local device/process/fleet vs remote service/region/IdP.", "Underlying data": "Cost and security matrices", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Show common-mode vs isolated failures.", "Caption": "Deployment changes the failure blast radius.", "Accessible alt text": "Diagram comparing local and remote MCP failure domains.", "id": "R10-VIS018", "sourceIds": [ "S121", "S057", "S132", "S131", "S133" ], "evidenceStatus": "curated-dataset-level-evidence; not an archive row-level citation mapping", "archive": { "namespace": "research/10/visual_specifications.json", "row": 18, "sourceIds": [], "raw": { "Title": "Failure Domains", "Purpose": "Local device/process/fleet vs remote service/region/IdP.", "Underlying data": "Cost and security matrices", "Protocol version": "Current", "Uncertainty notes": "Show common-mode vs isolated failures.", "Caption": "Deployment changes the failure blast radius.", "Accessible alt text": "Diagram comparing local and remote MCP failure domains." } }, "publicationStatus": "not-produced" } ] }